20070327
God Forbids if this is the new Trillian Logo
Just kidding. But apparently Adobe thinks so...
If you installed the Adobe Photoshop CS3 beta a few months ago, you probably thinks that it is a temporary icon...
No. This is it!!!
After you upgraded your computer from the 20th-century with Mac OS X or Windows Vista, both equipped with 128x128+ sized icons, all you can get from a creative software is a monolithic square.
This is not to say that I am against Minimalism. It is a noble attempt to integrate the two product lines with tens of products, from Adobe and the original Macromedia, under the same branding strategy.
Remember the older icons from Adobe? While the standard tools from the operating system would describe plainly what they do (e.g. Microsoft Paint is, apparently, a paint brush), the expensive tools are described with an abstract imagery to propose their superiority. For example, the icon of Adobe Photoshop 8 was a flying eye through a camera lens, and it described hardly what the tool does, though the branding designer would argue that the function of the tool is beyond your imagination, thus such imagery. A branded icon is 'sentimental': From the viewpoint of the company it describes their reach to the users, while from the viewpoint of the consumer it describes their pride in what they purchased.
Therefore, the design of the Adobe CS3 icons is so abstract that you cannot even imagine what the function of the tool is, or perhaps, Adobe thinks that it has become part of the human culture itself it will require no further explanation of what the tool does, thus flipping you a semantic two-letter combination. I would say that the ego of the company has grown beyond the level of software developer.
Minimalism is great if it is done like MUJI, which stands for "Good Products Without Branding" in Kanji. Here in the Adobe icons, Minimalism is employed in a totally opposite meaning: Maximum branding. While the minimal designs of MUJI products attempts to blend into your living room with coherent and simple materials, the minimal designs of the Adobe icons forms an uniform army on your desktop, screaming "You have been assimilated by Adobe so I want you to remember us all the time". Both resulted in coherence and clarity, which is the essence of employing Minimalism in a design, but their purposes are completely different.
Sorry for the lack of updates recently. I have been working on the famous bug #837 for a while now. That's why we have this icon talk right now. :)
